Top 8 Climbing Harnesses

Hoping to supplant your old exhausted tackle, move up to something somewhat fancier, or make your first climbing rigging buy? We looked into 50 of the freshest, most well known, and most adored saddles accessible for buy today, in the end narrowing down our determination to the best 8 to buy for similar dismemberment in this inside and out audit. Our analyzers logged endless days in these bridles, taking a greater number of falls than they want to concede while logging many pitches at a portion of the United State’s raddest and most acclaimed banks. From Red Rocks to Ten Sleep, Smith Rock to the Gunks, we utilized these bridles precisely how you will so we can prescribe the best decisions for hanging at a long belay, conveying a vast rack, or unending belay obligation at the exercise center.
Elizabeth following the crux rail traverse of Directissima at the Gunks. The Momentum is ideally suited for budget conscious rock climbers.
We tried and checked on these saddles amid the harvest time and late-fall of 2017, posting the most current data around Thanksgiving. In any case, promptly after the new year, Petzl discharged their new and refreshed variant of our Editors’ Choice winning Sama saddle, which we tried on winter climbing outings to the warm desert of Red Rocks, Nevada. The most refreshed adaptation of this audit was posted late March 2018; if it’s not too much trouble read on for more data! Despite your experience level or favored climbing disciplines, we have the correct master counsel that will facilitate your pursuit and help you locate the ideal bridle for your undertakings. While a large portion of these bridles are flawlessly appropriate for use by men or ladies, on the off chance that you need to find out about ladies’ particular outfits, look at our Best Climbing Harnesses for Women Review.

Best Overall

Petzl Sama

Editors’ Choice Award

$54.99

(21% off)

at MooseJaw

See It

See all costs (4 found)

Intended For: Sport, Trad | Weight (measure Medium): 13.7 oz.

Exceptionally agreeable, particularly to belay

Culminate plan of rigging circles for any style of shake climbing

Not so much massive but rather more versatile than past adaptation

Midriff belt rides up a bit when hanging

Not the best decision for ice, snow capped blended, or mountaineering

The recently upgraded Petzl Sama is the victor of our Best Overall Harness grant, and is our suggestion for practically any sort of shake climbing. While we effectively adored the past variant of this tackle, the updated one is far and away superior! We observed it to be exceptionally agreeable, paying little respect to whether one is hanging out that the base of a bluff, or hanging at belay numerous pitches off the ground. We likewise love the delightful way the flexible settled leg circles take into consideration enormously expanded versatility with no perceptible tightening influences of development. This was our most loved outfit to trad move in light of the super wide and inflexible front apparatus circles, joined with extensive and simpler to get to raise equip circles that gave us a lot of space for putting away all of our long course necessities. We can genuinely say that for a stone climbing outfit, this is the nearest one to consummate that we have ever worn.

Nothing is ever really impeccable, in any case, and the Sama still accompanies a few minor blemishes. In a few examples, we observed the Black Diamond Solution to be a hair more agreeable. The Sama additionally gauges a few ounces more than the lightest saddles that we tried. These imperfections are so minor as to barely be worth bringing up, however. Regardless of whether you favor stopping cams or cutting jolts, and particularly on the off chance that you incline toward both, the Sama won’t baffle.

Read audit: Petzl Sama

Top Pick for Sport and Gym Climbing

Dark Diamond Solution

Top Pick Award

$69.95

at REI

See It

See all costs (4 found)

Intended For: Sport | Weight (estimate Medium): 12 oz.

Combination Comfort Construction in both midsection belt and leg circles make it the most agreeable for hanging and belaying

Reasonable

Light and super packable

Apparatus circles too little for successive use as a trad climbing bridle

Highlights don’t oblige other climbing disciplines, usable essentially just for game and exercise center climbing

Searching for the most agreeable bridle you can discover, paying little heed to whether you are belaying your amigo for a considerable length of time on his undertaking, hanging and falling more than once as you suss out the essence moves, or basically hanging out at the base of the ridge for a long time? Look no more distant than the Black Diamond Solution. It includes a thin and softly cushioned midriff belt that is far more extensive than most, and emulates this plan for the leg circles too. It utilizes Fusion Comfort Construction, which means it utilizes three thin pieces of webbing spread out through the abdomen belt and leg circles to help diffuse the weight against the back, hips, and hamstrings. The outcome is the most agreeable saddle we have ever worn, and it comes at a sensible cost of just $69 retail.

Worth specifying, in any case, is that the Solution accompanies the drawback that its list of capabilities (insignificant little rigging circles, no pull circle, settled width leg circles), block it from broad use on bigger climbing targets. While there is room on its rigging circles for a light rack in the event that you happen to wind up out for multi day of trad cragging, it would not be the saddle of decision for long free or snow capped courses. In any case, if your climbing days are fundamentally spent section jolts or hitting the exercise center, we don’t feel there is any better tackle you could purchase.

Read survey: Black Diamond Solution

Top Pick for Versatility

Arc’teryx AR-395a

Top Pick Award

$126.99

(20% off)

at MooseJaw

See It

See all costs (2 found)

Intended For: Sport, trad, snow capped, blended, ice | Weight (estimate Medium): 14.1 oz.

The best list of capabilities found on any tackle!

Ideally intended for any kind of climbing: trad, sport, rec center, snow capped, ice, or mountaineering

Low profile is effortlessly packable and wears serenely added to a pack abdomen repertoire

It’s Arc’teryx, so obviously it’s expensive

Leg circle configuration cuts off flow effectively, not as agreeable for hanging or belaying as others

What we completely adored about the AR-395a was its amazing adaptability and wonderful list of capabilities. On the off chance that you need to possess one single bridle that is in a perfect world suited to each sort of moving in each season, this is without uncertainty your decision. The goliath design circles are ideal for game climbing or trad cragging, and there is bounty enough space for every one of the additional items required on long free or high courses. Customizable leg circles enable you to remain agreeable regardless of how cumbersome (or not) your apparel is, and four ice cut connection focuses offer awesome winter climbing flexibility. At last, the abdomen belt is super thin and lies level against the hips and back, so in the event that you are mountaineering or snow capped moving with a pack, the hip belt will ride easily preposterous of the saddle.

The main thing keeping the Arc’teryx AR-395a from acknowledgment as the simple best in this survey was the way that its leg circles were a bit too thin where they wrap inside the legs and over the femoral course, so we observed it to be a hair less agreeable for hanging and epic belaying sessions than the Petzl Sama or Black Diamond Solution. Obviously, any individual who has spent a hour or two at a hanging belay realizes that no saddle is genuinely everything that agreeable to hang in, so this grumbling is moderately minor in the excellent plan of things. While it wasn’t our most elevated scoring bridle, it was pretty darn close and is a great decision for anybody willing to contribute the cash. Not exclusively is it the most adaptable for all styles of climbing, however is our best decision for ice or snow capped moving too.

Read survey: Arc’teryx AR-395a

Best Bang for the Buck

Dark Diamond Momentum

Best Buy Award

$32.73

(40% off)

at REI

See It

See all costs (4 found)

Intended For: Sport, trad | Weight (estimate Medium): 12.1 oz.

For just $55 retail, offers about indistinguishable execution from outfits costing $125

The least difficult and most straightforward to utilize leg circle change clasps

Inflexible and level apparatus circles make for simplest section and unclipping of biners

Abdomen belt estimating appears to keep running on the little side

Froth cushioning bulkier than generally saddles

Apparatus circles on the little side for conveying a full trad rack

The Black Diamond Momentum tackle retails for a minor $55, making it the second most reasonable climbing bridle in this survey. In any case, what extremely made it deserving of our Best Bang for the Buck Award was the way that it scored precisely the equivalent as the top of the line Black Diamond Chaos bridle, which retails for more than twofold what the Momentum does. You read that right — the Momentum offers top of the line execution at a storm cellar level cost! This tackle is likewise outstanding for the way that it has the least difficult and simplest to alter leg circles, has every one of the highlights you requirement for most sorts of climbing, and is quite agreeable as saddles go.

Important is that this tackle was more awkward for hanging sessions and logging belay obligation than the Petzl Sama or Black Diamond Solution. It additionally has disappointingly little apparatus circles in the event that you are planning to convey an entire trad rack. Consequently it wouldn’t be our first proposal for long shake courses or elevated climbing, however we think it is an ideal decision for an amateur climber who wouldn’t like to use up every last cent, as it offers better than expected execution whether you are utilizing it to move in the rec center, at the game precipice, or for moderate trad cragging.

Read survey: Black Diamond Momentum

An Affordable Harness with Two-Buckle Adjustability

Petzl Corax

$59.95

at REI

See It

See all costs (4 found)

Intended For: Sport and trad, mountaineering, by means of ferrata | Weight (estimate Medium): 15.4 oz.

Immense scope of customizability

Twofold midsection clasps mean tackle is constantly focused

Agreeable and economical

Overwhelming and cumbersome

Twofold abdomen clasps implies heaps of fiddling for modifications

You may have seen that the Black Diamond Momentum, while offering great execution at a low value, fits little and does not have a wide size range. You likewise may have seen that the most flexible saddle in this audit, the Arc’teryx AR-395a, is additionally by a long shot the most costly. The Corax is a decent option in contrast to both of these alternatives since it is moderate, flexible, and exceedingly movable. Its most one of a kind component is twofold auto-locking clasps at the front of the abdomen belt, instead of a solitary clasp found on every single different outfit. This is decent in light of the fact that it takes into account a far more extensive scope of movability, helpful for specific conditions, for example, simple sharing of an outfit. It additionally implies that regardless of how tight or free the midsection belt is, the belay circle in front and rigging circles on the sides dependably remain focused, which isn’t the situation for single clasp outlines, particularly when worn close to the furthest reaches of their size range.

The guideline drawback to the Corax is that it is cumbersome and substantial. In spite of just weighing 3.5 ounces more than the lightest tackle we tried, the Corax feels far heavier than that and doesn’t pack down well to fit into a pack. While the Corax was not one of the most astounding scoring items in this survey, it is as yet an agreeable tackle with interesting highlights that make it worth a look as an option in contrast to a portion of our honor champs. It is a decent tackle choice for the individuals who need an extremely moderate yet additionally exceptionally movable saddle, and the individuals who need an extremely flexible yet at the same time reasonable outfit.

Read survey: Petzl Corax

Examination and Test Results

To have the capacity to give the most ideal tackle suggestions, we tried every one of the eight outfits widely over a multi month time span, with numerous individuals wearing and giving their sentiments on each bridle. The lion’s share of our testing occurred outside at precipices in the mountain west: neighborhood ridges close Ouray, Colorado, at Ten Sleep, Wyoming, Red Rocks, Nevada, and even the Gunks in New York. We took broad notes all through the testing time frame and had a quite smart thought of the benefits of each after the trial was finished, however lined up our sentiments with controlled tests to contrast each tackle with all the others over an assortment of measurements.

Pulling through the low soak proceeds onward a mainstream move at the Motherlode an excellent precipice high in the San Juan Mountains while wearing the Edelrid Zack saddle.

Pulling through the low soak proceeds onward a mainstream move at the Motherlode, an excellent precipice high in the San Juan Mountains, while wearing the Edelrid Zack saddle.

To speak to which were the best by and large outfits, we evaluated each for five individual measurements on a size of 1-10. We at that point weighted every metric in light of the fact that it was so imperative to the general execution of an outfit, and added every one of the scores together to concoct a general score between 1-100. In all cases, scores were granted in light of execution contrasted with the opposition. A low scoring bridle may not be an awful item by any stretch of the imagination, but rather essentially didn’t execute and in addition the others. Huge numbers of the tackles tried are intended for particular purposes, so on the grounds that an item has a high (or low) generally speaking score does not mean it is or isn’t the best decision for you. Dig further into the individual measurements to discover the bridle that best meets your requirements. The individual measurements that we reviewed for, including what rate they represented an item’s last score, and the best entertainers for that metric, are depicted in more noteworthy detail underneath.

As the best tackle for game climbing we normally feel that its best application is cutting jolts as we are here in the Dihedrals region at Smith Rock.

As the best outfit for game climbing, we normally believe that its best application is cutting jolts, as we are here in the Dihedrals zone at Smith Rock.

Esteem

Searching for an awesome all around bridle without burning up all available resources? We set up together the table underneath to help picture how every contender in our audit stacked up against the rest as far as esteem, dictated by valuable highlights in respect to list cost. Float over each dab to see which tackle it speaks to, with honor victors being set apart by blue spots. As should be obvious, grant victors, for example, the Petzl Sama, Black Diamond Solution, and Black Diamond Momentum fall promote into the lower right quadrant and in this manner speak to a superior esteem.

Hanging Comfort

The guideline capacity of a climbing tackle is to get you when you fall and to hold you securely against the precipice when required. These saddles completed an incredible activity of this, and one need not stress over the security of the bridle, whenever utilized accurately, when climbing. Then again, how agreeable an outfit felt while hanging in it changed definitely. Look at the table beneath to perceive how the opposition stacked up when it came to hanging solace.

We will give you access on a straightforward truth with regards to hanging in a climbing saddle: it isn’t happy. While this fact may not enroll in your awareness as you work your way up a lofty game ascension, any individual who has spent a hour or so at a hanging belay sitting tight for their accomplice to complete their lead can confirm the immense uneasiness of hanging in a tackle for a significant lot. Climbing bridles have texture that folds over the abdomen, bring down back, and back of the thighs, which is important for security. In any case, the reality remains that these parts of your body are not intended to specifically hold weight for significant lots of time, and the weight put on them winds up awkward or even difficult rather rapidly. While each bridle utilizes an alternate system to diffuse or cushion against the heap, none of them approach the impression of sitting in a seat or on the lounge chair. Maybe this metric ought to be better idea of as minimum hanging uneasiness, instead of “hanging solace.”

To test hanging solace some of the time we simply chose to take a break. Here on top-rope in the San Juan Mountains. The Momentum didn’t let us down however wasn’t a standout amongst the most agreeable for staying nearby in.

To test hanging solace, now and again we simply chose to take a break. Here on top-rope in the San Juan Mountains. The Momentum didn’t let us down, however wasn’t a standout amongst the most agreeable for staying nearby in.

To decisively say which bridles were the minimum awkward while hanging in them, we posted up at the base of a nearby precipice and burned through eight minutes progressively free-hanging in each outfit, in a steady progression. While this measure of time doesn’t come close to a genuine hanging belay, we can guarantee you it was a lot of time to comprehend the benefits or degradations of each tackle and analyze them decently. This test copied the positions found in a hanging belay while swinging from the rope subsequent to falling or taking, and keeping in mind that rappelling. Apparent to us was that in this position, a man’s weight is circulated between the midriff belt and the leg circles, however not equitably. We gauge that 60% or so of the power laid on the legs, with 40% or less on the lower back. Considering this, the plan of the leg circles had a more basic impact on balancing solace than the outline of the midsection belt.

Hanging out at the base of the ridge in the BD Chaos we found that its leg circles were entirely comfortable for hanging in yet not as much as the ultra wide leg circles found on the Solution.

Hanging out at the base of the ridge in the BD Chaos, we found that its leg circles were really comfortable for hanging in, however not as much as the ultra wide leg circles found on the Solution.

The “Combination Comfort Construction” of the Black Diamond Solution ended up being the most agreeable tackle to hang in. A substantial piece of this finding was on account of it had the most stretched out leg circles that likewise attempted to diffuse the heap similarly that its abdomen belt did. Leg circle plans that were more slender or diffused the heap with a solitary tie of webbing, particularly where the circles kept running inside the legs and over the femoral course, prompted cut off flow and were perceptibly less agreeable, quickly. The wide and all around cushioned leg circles on the Petzl Sama, and also the Petzl Aquila, took into account the second minimum awkward hanging knowledge. As the absolute most vital viewpoint while thinking about the execution of a tackle, we weighted this metric as 35% of an item’s general score.

The triangle of texture appeared in this photograph completes a great job of keeping the leg circles set up as they fold over the front of the leg. In spite of its generally thin plan the Petzl Aquila was for sure a comfortable bridle to hang in.

The triangle of texture appeared in this photograph completes a great job of keeping the leg circles set up as they fold over the front of the leg. Notwithstanding its moderately thin plan, the Petzl Aquila was for sure a comfortable saddle to hang in.

Standing Comfort and Mobility

In the event that you are wearing an outfit however aren’t hanging at a belay or rappelling off a precipice, at that point chances are you are moving near, climbing, strolling, or just remaining about at the base of the bluff. This metric was intended to evaluate how agreeable an outfit is amid these non-hanging minutes, which is most of the time while you wear a tackle. Look at the table beneath to see where every contender positioned for Standing Comfort and Mobility.

While we at first thought about this metric as “portability while climbing,” we found that while really climbing, we were generally so occupied with what we were doing that we never saw our tackle by any stretch of the imagination! Unarguably, this is something to be thankful for, yet didn’t give us much to utilize when looking at models. So we rather appraised their solace amid minutes when we do see them: remaining around, strolling about, and climbing. We additionally incorporated into this metric how agreeable each bridle was while conveying a full rack while wearing stores of additional dress, and keeping in mind that conveying a climbing pack. To test them, we took nitty gritty notes while doing every one of the above things wearing each outfit and after that amalgamated the discoveries into a general Standing Comfort and Mobility Rating.

Lead belaying does not put any weight on the bridle or the wearer until the point that the pioneer falls. Right then and there the belayer will absolutely see whether they are wearing an agreeable bridle or not and the Solution appeared here in Smith Rock was the best for this reason.

Lead belaying does not put any weight on the bridle or the wearer until the point that the pioneer falls. Right then and there, the belayer will positively see whether they are wearing an agreeable saddle or not, and the Solution, appeared here in Smith Rock, was the best for this reason.

By and by, our Editors’ Choice Award-winning Black Diamond Solution was the most agreeable saddle for the majority of the non-hanging times. Its wide midsection and leg circles are negligibly cushioned so that there is no cumbersomeness to block development or give a diversion. Its thin abdomen belt sat easily added to the hip repertoire of our climbing pack, and it held the heaviness of a rack without drooping or putting weight on the hips. The Arc’teryx AR-395a was the second most noteworthy scorer in this metric, for fundamentally the same as reasons, however had a gentle inclination to rub and abrade at our lower back now and again while conveying a substantial rack. Behind those two thin and negligibly cushioned models were the Black Diamond Chaos and Momentum, and additionally the Petzl Corax, which all utilized an assortment of froth cushioning to achieve an agreeable fit with more mass and somewhat less versatility. As a vital metric to the execution and satisfaction in a tackle, we weighted this metric as 20% of an item’s general score.

Indeed, even while conveying an entirely overwhelming rack the AR-395a sat pleasantly on our hips without undue descending weight. This is a decent outfit for hanging out in while not moving much more agreeable than most.

Indeed, even while conveying a really substantial rack, the AR-395a sat pleasantly on our hips without undue descending weight. This is a decent saddle for hanging out in while not moving, much more agreeable than most.

Highlights

Climbing outfits have some particular highlights that make them increasingly (or less) agreeable or flexible or enable you to convey the apparatus you require when climbing. A portion of these highlights incorporate flexible leg circles, auto-bolting twofold supported wellbeing clasps, strengthened tie-in circles, adapt circles, a pull circle, and openings to add on ice scissors to hold ice tightens and instruments the winter. The specific highlights included on each bridle, and how they perform, assumes an expansive job in separating whether an outfit will be a decent decision for specific controls, for example, sport versus elevated climbing. Take a gander at the unobtrusive highlights of a tackle before obtaining to make sure you get one perfect for what you need to utilize it for. The table beneath shows how the opposition stacked up.

The rigging circles on the AR-395a are enormous and can hold more apparatus than we’d jump at the chance to convey at one time.

The apparatus circles on the AR-395a are gigantic and can hold more rigging than we’d get a kick out of the chance to convey at one time.

To rate for highlights, we took a gander at what includes a saddle had and surveyed how well they functioned contrasted with the opposition. We didn’t punish an item to have less highlights yet rewarded items that had more highlights, as long as they functioned admirably. Make sure to look at the individual surveys for a summary of the highlights found on each saddle and how well they functioned. We can’t pressure how essential this is: for example, the BD Solution, our second most noteworthy appraised contender, has a list of capabilities reasonable just for game climbing, and would be a frustrating buy for a man needing to basically climb long free courses.

Elizabeth obtained this saddle for multi day at the Gunks and continued to pile on. While she made it work things got somewhat tight on the little rigging circles of the Momentum. Plainly you can make it work in the event that you need to yet on the off chance that you are purchasing a tackle for the most part trad climbing we suggest one with greater apparatus circles.

Elizabeth acquired this outfit for multi day at the Gunks and continued to pile on. While she made it work, things got somewhat tight on the little rigging circles of the Momentum. Obviously you can make it work in the event that you need to, however on the off chance that you are purchasing a bridle for generally trad climbing, we prescribe one with greater apparatus circles.

At last, two bridles — the Petzl Sama and the Arc’teryx AR-395a — had highlight sets that far beat the opposition. The AR-395a had by a long shot the most highlights, settling on it a best decision for truly every style of climbing, in spite of the fact that we had a minor protest with the state of the apparatus circles and the unrated pull circle. Then again, the Sama had somewhat less highlights, yet we actually couldn’t discover blame with any of them. The Black Diamond Chaos and Momentum additionally had extraordinary highlights, in spite of the fact that we could discover little protests with each thus granted them one less point. As a standout amongst the most separating parts of bridle outline, we weighted highlights as 20% of an item’s last score.

The coolest element on the Momentum is these trakFit leg circles agents that fix or release the fit just by sliding them back or forward the speediest and most effortless leg circle modification framework we have seen.

The coolest component on the Momentum is these trakFit leg circles agents that fix or release the fit just by sliding them back or forward, the snappiest and least demanding leg circle alteration framework we have seen.

Belaying Comfort

You can’t eat a PB&J sandwich without the jam, and you can’t go moving without likewise belaying. Except if your accomplice is named Alex Honnold, you’re most likely going to spend a reasonable lump of your belay time holding your accomplice as they canine on lead or enjoy a reprieve while top-restricting. Holding a climber while belaying puts a considerable upward draw on your saddle that restricts the power for the most part in the leg circles, particularly as they fold over within the leg to meet at the belay circle in the front. The dissemination of this weight is totally unique in relation to that found while hanging in a saddle, so we chose to rate bridle comfort independently to belay. How each saddle stacked up to our tests can be found in the beneath graph.

By and by, holding a man for quite a while belaying isn’t what a great many people would call agreeable. Like when looking at bridles for hanging solace, we before long understood that reasoning with respect to “minimum awkward” was more beneficial. To test this metric precisely, we analyzed them consistently by holding a climber on top-rope for a couple of minutes on end in each saddle. The best outfits had the most agreeable leg circles that would sit level against the leg as it folded over within to meet at the belay circle. The most awkward felt like we were being gouged by the sharp edge of a bit of webbing, which we generally were. Important is that with a legitimately fitting saddle, fellows can rest guaranteed that these outfits are intended to permit everything to hang right and not get squeezed or pulverized while belaying, in spite of the fact that we saw that when wearing jeans with bulkier or thicker material, there is a more noteworthy possibility that some change will be fundamental.

Not lacking for perspectives! Testing the Edelrid Zack’s solace while belaying. Because of a firm and not super happy with cushioning framework it was not one of our best decisions for broadened belay obligation.

Not lacking for perspectives! Testing the Edelrid Zack’s solace while belaying. Because of a solid and not super open to cushioning framework, it was not one of our best decisions for expanded belay obligation.

As opposed to our appraisal for hanging solace and standing solace, the recently overhauled Petzl Sama was the slightest awkward outfit to belay for expanded timeframes in, with the Solution arriving in a nearby second. Notwithstanding these two champions, the Black Diamond Chaos, and in addition the Petzl Aquila, were both moderately “not awkward” to belay in for broadened periods. Tragically, we found that the thin and level pieces of texture found on within the leg circles of the Arc-teryx AR-395a piece into our femoral district more violently than most, and this flaw was presumably the main thing shielding it from being the best by and large scorer. As a metric that isn’t exactly as critical as the three, we have effectively portrayed, belaying solace represented 15% of an item’s last score.

Holding somebody educated while belaying incorporates the powers within the leg. The Aquila was a standout amongst the most agreeable bridles for belaying in appeared here high in the Wooden Ship crevasse at Smith Rock.

Holding somebody instructed while belaying brings together the powers within the leg. The Aquila was a standout amongst the most agreeable tackles for belaying in, appeared here high in the Wooden Ship chasm at Smith Rock.

Flexibility

The majority of the saddles looked into here are intended to be utilized for climbing, however in all actuality there are a wide range of types of climbing: sport, exercise center, trad, ice, snow capped shake, elevated blended, and mountaineering. It is conceivable to purchase a saddle particularly intended for and customized to every one of these reasons, and in fact a portion of the outfits here just fit a tight scope of utilization. Then again, most by far of climbers we know positively do

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *